Net neutrality: FCC proposes three new rules | csmonitor.com

Net neutrality: FCC proposes three new rules | csmonitor.com

Shared via AddThis

So I'm always a little skeptical anytime any federal organization decides that it can delve into the workings of the private sector, however, on its face, it would seem as if the FCC could deserve commendation for possibly arresting the efforts of some ISPs to limit (censor?) content that flows through their pipelines.

Still, I have some concerns and here they are:

First off, I want to embrace this move as I am an avid user of tech and I like my freedom. Ever since Comcast has introduced their bandwidth cap policy, I have been a bit apprehensive that one day my internet service provider is going to tell me that my my (legal) music downloading, video streaming and online gaming are going to cost me an arm and or a leg or worse that I am not allowed to do these things anymore.

Still, I cannot help but feel a twinge of concern for the notions of free market capitalism. If for example, a group of criminals was utilizing the web for say, illegal video downloading (For the purpose of bootleg video sales perhaps) and ISP XYZ has a strong suspicion that this activity is going on, then should that ISP not be allowed to limit this behavior? Such criminal activity would surely sap valuable bandwidth and strain the ISPs resources which would surely cause harm to the ISP right?

The other question that occurs to me and that I've yet to answer is whether US citizens (or anyone for that matter) has a right to the internet. If we don't have a right to the internet, then we surely must accept the terms and conditions that the various companies offer. We may not like it, but because its not a fundamental right, we have no right to change the terms and conditions other than by choosing a different provider (If available).

If we do have a right to the internet then I can see regulation as being more acceptable (Though regulation tends to be a double edged sword).

Hence, I am a bit conflicted over which position to take on this issue and I'd love to hear what you guys think about this.

Konrad